Today in the Mission Yearbook

The people healing the world often themselves need healing


Pastor offers suggestions for overcoming compassion fatigue

March 18, 2019

The Rev. Dr. Dana Sutton, of Sutton Coaching, led a webinar Monday on overcoming compassion fatigue in ministry.

Compassion fatigue — that malady that many pastors, first responders and others in helping professions suffer that can leave them feeling isolated, tired, trapped or worse — can be overcome, and there’s help for those who, as the Rev. Dr. Dana Sutton put it, “are healing the world and need to heal themselves.”

Originally used to label PTSD-like symptoms of disaster recovery and first responder personnel, Sutton said, compassion fatigue also describes longer term effects on those who give of themselves without regard to the cost or the need to monitor and refill their own reserves.

According to Sutton, an experienced pastor who’s part of the Presbyterian Coach Network, as pastors work to help congregants, many develop this formula: I win only if you win first. But it has a downside: When the pastor works to help the person win — but the person doesn’t — then the pastor loses, and feelings of apathy and helplessness can occur. “We can’t always win, and that ends up looking like compassion fatigue,” Sutton said. “We find ourselves drained and have to get back in a compassionate state.”

Sutton has three suggestions for doing that:

  • Rekindle your sense of wonder by finding an activity so fascinating that you lose track of time. Pursuits can include writing, painting or listening to music.
  • Be in touch with your deeper spiritual self, and God’s self, “in ways that aren’t part of our jobs or expectations, just in ways that feed us — whatever is spiritual or healing and brings you deep contentment and joy without self-judgment,” Sutton suggested. Possible activities range from prayer and yoga to a daily walk or pre-bed Examen.
  • Cultivate a perspective of abundance, because compassion fatigue is borne out of a perspective of “No matter how little we have, there is enough to go around — enough for others and for ourselves.”

With an eye on God’s abundance, “We start with the choice to believe that I am good enough and God is good enough and will always provide what’s needed,” he said. “We put ourselves and our souls into the world as helpers because it is who we are.” But “saving, healing and fixing things or people are not really in our power.”

Many churches today “experience scarcity based on what they used to have,” including plenty of members and money, he said. “Yet what abundance is God still offering? No matter what, I fully believe grace and enjoyment are part of the experience to which God calls us.”

The Rev. Dr. Laurie Kraus is director of Presbyterian Disaster Assistance.

The Rev. Dr. Laurie Kraus, Presbyterian Disaster Assistance director, literally helped write the book on compassion fatigue prevention and resilience, a workbook that PDA has used over the years to train tens of thousands of responders in need of spiritual and emotional care after spending months or years in the field.

The approach described by Kraus, who’s a certified compassion fatigue professional, PDA’s the Rev. Dr. Jim Kirk and the Rev. Bruce G. Wismer — adapted from work by J. Eric Gentry and Anna Baranowsky — has these steps for building resilience:

  • Self-regulation, which requires relaxation.
  • Intentionality, the ability to pursue your mission with integrity and follow the path in the direction you’re aimed.
  • Perceptual maturation, recognizing the good in the work you do and remaining relaxed when another is angry or judgmental toward you.
  • Connection/support, with three or more peers who can listen without judgment or interruption while you’re sharing uncomfortable information on what you’ve witnessed.
  • Self-care, the ability to monitor and care for physical, emotional and spiritual needs, including at least one aerobic activity done at least three times weekly.

Kraus said there’s generally “a huge attrition” among response leadership about two years following a large disaster. Responders and helpers can be subject to the same challenges as members of the general population, including increased cases of domestic violence, depression and suicide, she said.

“It happens to a lot of people, but it’s not a necessity,” she said, adding that PDA’s prevention and resilience training features this quote from Austrian neurologist and psychiatrist Viktor Frankl, a Holocaust survivor: “That which is to give light must endure burning.” Or there’s this quote, cited often by people practicing mindfulness: “Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.”

Mike Ferguson, Editor, Presbyterian News Service, Communications, Presbyterian Mission Agency

Today’s Focus:  Overcoming Compassion Fatigue

Let us join in prayer for: 

PC(USA) Agencies’ Staff

Kathy Melvin, PMA
Terri Milburn, ASG

Let us pray:

Beloved God, we want to love you with all our heart, soul, mind and strength. Help us to read your Word and understand that the truth that will set us free. Teach us so that we too can teach like you. Amen.

Daily Readings