Moving exercise condenses half a millennium into 50 minutes
February 27, 2019
One day, the Rev. Irvin Porter invited about four dozen staff working at the Presbyterian Center to stand on the blanket of their choosing among about 20 covering a conference room floor.
As he and three others read from a script created by the group Roots of Injustice, Seeds of Change: Toward Right Relationship with Native Peoples — which outlined the cruel effects the Doctrine of Discovery had on Native Americans — an assistant periodically rolled up corners and edges of the blankets until there was scant room for participants to stand.
As the blanket exercise played out, crowd members — playing the part of the up to 30 million Native Americans present in what Europeans called the New World when Christopher Columbus landed on Caribbean islands more than five centuries ago — took a seat as disease, warfare, broken treaties, forced migration and mandatory boarding school took their toll. In the end, a half-dozen people remained standing on the gathered-up blankets.
“If you’ve never heard this before, you’re not alone. This is the kind of history nobody cares about,” said Porter, associate for Native American Congregational Support for the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.). The mission, he said, is to “wake us up that this happened. We as a denomination are trying to blunt this racism.”
Porter, an enrolled member of the Pima Tribe who’s also descended from the Nez Perce and T’hono O’odham tribes, is also part-time pastor of Church of the Indian Fellowship in Tacoma, Washington. He noted that in 2016, the 222nd General Assembly repudiated the Doctrine of Discovery, a Columbus-era papal policy that sought to justify the seizure of land and the murder and enslavement of any of its occupants who weren’t Christian.
While Columbus wrote that with 50 men, “we could subjugate (Caribbean indigenous people) and do whatever we want,” on occasion relations were more cordial. Natives taught British colonists the reliability and synergy of their Three Sisters diet – corn, beans and squash. Colonists for a time recognized Native Americans’ distinct, self-governing societies, and worked out treaties indigenous people held as sacred agreements. In the end, about 400 treaties were signed and then broken.
“To Europeans,” Porter said, “land was a commodity.”
The blanket exercise hit on a number of events familiar to high school history students, including the Indian Removal Act and subsequent Trail of Tears; the 1887 Dawes Act, which sold 90 million acres of ancestral tribal lands at cut-rate prices to non-Indian settlers and which Theodore Roosevelt called “a mighty pulverizing engine to break up the tribal mass”; and the 1978 Indian Child Welfare Act, which governs the way Native American children can be removed from their families.
In fact, the accounts of indigenous people constitute important history, as Rio Ramirez, a Tohono O’odham educator in Tucson, wrote: “Knowing this country’s history is the first step we need to take in the long process of repairing our people and our land. … Sometimes when people learn about the broken treaties, relocation and genocide, they feel guilty about what happened to Native Americans. Those feelings are OK as long as we move past them and try to help each other now as human beings.
“No one here today made these things happen. But we are the ones who are living now, and we need to understand that we are all in this together.”
Mike Ferguson, Presbyterian News Service, Presbyterian Mission Agency
Today’s Focus: Doctrine of Discovery
Let us join in prayer for:
PC(USA) Agencies’ Staff
Let us pray:
Creator of all we see and all we cannot see, your Spirit has been with us from the beginning and will be with us through all time. We thank you for the gift of life, and for the gift of the earth that is our home. May we live with gratitude in our hearts each day as we seek to be faithful witnesses of your good news. Amen.